TL;DR
Spartan Metals’ preliminary economic assessment estimates a $683 million initial cost for a 24-year underground tungsten and molybdenum operation at Victorio in New Mexico. The study projects a $2.14 billion after-tax net present value at an 8% discount rate, but its lower-price scenario cuts that figure to $392 million, and 39% of scheduled plant feed is inferred resources.
Spartan Metals estimates it would cost $683 million (C$978 million) to build its proposed underground tungsten and molybdenum mine at Victorio in New Mexico, according to a preliminary economic assessment released Thursday. The study projects a 24-year operation with a $2.14 billion after-tax net present value at an 8% discount rate, but those economics depend on metal prices and further project work.
Get smart everyday buys delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The assessment forecasts a 31% internal rate of return at the commodity-price assumptions used in its base case: $1,350 per 10 kg of tungsten trioxide and $20 per pound of molybdenum. It also estimates another $2.03 billion in sustaining expenditure over the mine’s life, separate from the initial construction estimate. The preliminary study’s figures are estimates, not a construction decision or a guarantee of future returns.
At the lowest prices tested—$750 per 10 kg of tungsten trioxide and $15 per pound of molybdenum—the after-tax NPV falls to $392 million and the projected return to 14%. Spartan CEO Brett Marsh said both metals contribute to the project’s economics, making changes in either price relevant. The study projects yearly recovery of about 4,100 tonnes of tungsten trioxide contained in ammonium paratungstate, plus 8.65 million pounds of molybdenum in concentrate.
Victorio would use block caving, an underground mining method that relies on gravity to break rock. The proposed plant would process tungsten concentrate into ammonium paratungstate, a feedstock used in cutting tools and other industrial products. The project is about 440 km southwest of Santa Fe. Spartan’s shares closed unchanged at C$0.26 in Toronto on Thursday, giving the company a market value of about C$15.4 million, or US$10.7 million.
What Spartan’s $683M Price Tag Means For Victorio
Spartan Metals’ preliminary assessment outlines a large, long-life mine with returns that depend on metal prices and further study.
The economics are price-sensitive
The assessment projects a 31% return in its base case and 14% at the lowest tested metal prices.
- $1,350 per 10 kg of tungsten trioxide
- $20 per pound of molybdenum
- $2.14B after-tax NPV
- $750 per 10 kg of tungsten trioxide
- $15 per pound of molybdenum
- $392M after-tax NPV
A potential domestic supply source
Victorio could add U.S. production of metals used in industrial and defense applications.
Supply gap
The United States last mined tungsten commercially in 2015. China accounts for about 85% of global ammonium paratungstate refining capacity.
Second contributor
Both metals contribute to the project’s projected economics, so price changes in either matter.
Important uncertainties remain
The preliminary study leaves geology, costs and financing open for further work.
What comes next
Spartan plans to advance Victorio to prefeasibility.
The recommended $13.2M program includes drilling, metallurgical testing, and water supply and tailings studies.
Financing, the claims option and development plans remain open; no construction schedule is stated.
A Domestic Tungsten Supply Case
The proposal would target a supply gap for a metal used in industrial and defense applications. The United States last mined tungsten commercially in 2015, according to the U.S. Geological Survey. S&P Global says China accounts for about 85% of global capacity to refine ammonium paratungstate, the intermediate product Victorio would make. That concentration leaves buyers exposed to supply conditions in a market where export controls are keeping supply tight, according to Fastmarkets.
If developed, Victorio could add a domestic source of both tungsten and molybdenum. Marsh described it as a potential long-term supplier to U.S. industrial and defense customers. That is a company view of the project’s possible role, not evidence that the mine is approved, financed or able to meet future demand. The assessment gives readers an early picture of the potential scale, alongside substantial capital needs and sensitivity to commodity prices.
The cost estimate also needs to be read against Spartan’s current scale: the company’s reported market value was about C$15.4 million, far below the proposed initial build cost. That comparison does not establish how Spartan might fund development; the assessment does not set out a completed financing plan. Moving from an economic assessment to construction would require further study, funding and project decisions.
Products Worth Considering

Dell UltraSharp U2424H 24-Inch FHD Monitor

Dell UltraSharp 27 Thunderbolt Hub Monitor (U2726DER), QHD

Dell XPS 13 13.4-Inch Touchscreen Laptop, Intel Core 5 320, 16GB RAM, 512GB SSD
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Resources and Study Limitations
An August resource estimate reported 76.7 million measured and indicated tonnes, grading 0.1% tungsten trioxide and 0.09% molybdenum. It also reported 92.4 million inferred tonnes, grading 0.09% tungsten trioxide and 0.06% molybdenum. The assessment schedules inferred resources as 39% of plant feed. That proportion matters because inferred resources have less geological confidence than measured and indicated resources; their inclusion is one factor readers should keep in mind when weighing a preliminary assessment.
The study recommends $13.2 million of additional work, including drilling, metallurgical testing and studies of water supply and tailings. Spartan plans to advance Victorio to a prefeasibility study. The company holds an option on the core claims from Donegan Resources under a March agreement. Exercising the option requires cash payments, $14 million in exploration spending and completion of a feasibility study by 2034.
Victorio is part of wider efforts to advance tungsten projects in North America, but those developments do not determine its prospects. Canada’s federal government conditionally approved up to C$14 million in financing for Fireweed Metals on Monday to help advance its Mactung project toward a construction decision. That is a separate project and funding development, rather than financing for Spartan.
“Both metals contribute to those economics, so continued price appreciation for either metal can make a meaningful difference to the underlying project economics.”
— Brett Marsh, Spartan Metals CEO
Costs, Resources and Financing Remain Open
The assessment is preliminary, and key details remain unresolved. The recommended drilling, metallurgical work, water-supply analysis and tailings studies have not yet established the project’s final design or costs. The study’s $683 million initial estimate is not the full projected spending over the mine’s life; it separately estimates $2.03 billion in sustaining expenditure.
It is also not clear how Spartan would finance construction, whether it will exercise its option on the core claims, or how future studies may change the project’s economics. The scheduled use of 39% inferred resources adds geological uncertainty that further work would need to address. Commodity prices may also differ from the assessment’s assumptions; its tested low-price case shows a marked reduction in projected returns, but does not predict actual future prices.
Prefeasibility Work Is the Next Test
Spartan plans to advance Victorio to prefeasibility, beginning with work estimated at $13.2 million. The proposed program includes drilling, metallurgical testing and studies of water supply and tailings. Those results should provide more information about the deposit, processing approach and infrastructure requirements, and could change the current estimates.
Separately, the claims option has obligations that include cash payments, $14 million in exploration spending and a feasibility study by 2034 under the March agreement. The immediate milestones are the additional technical studies and Spartan’s decisions about the option and development program. No construction schedule or financing package is stated in the assessment. Until further studies and decisions are made, Victorio’s construction cost and projected returns remain preliminary estimates.
Source: rss
Key Questions
What does Spartan estimate it would cost to build Victorio?
The preliminary economic assessment estimates an initial construction cost of $683 million (C$978 million). It also projects another $2.03 billion in sustaining spending over the mine’s 24-year life.
What returns does the study project?
At its stated base-case assumptions, the study estimates a $2.14 billion after-tax NPV at an 8% discount rate and a 31% internal rate of return. These are study projections, not guaranteed outcomes.
How much do the projections change in the lower-price case?
At $750 per 10 kg of tungsten trioxide and $15 per pound of molybdenum, the assessment’s after-tax NPV falls to $392 million and its projected return to 14%.
Is Victorio approved for construction?
The information provided describes a preliminary economic assessment and Spartan’s plan to advance to prefeasibility. It does not report a construction approval, completed financing plan or construction schedule.
What work is planned next?
The assessment recommends $13.2 million of further work, including drilling, metallurgical testing and studies of water supply and tailings, as Spartan advances toward prefeasibility.
Source: northernminer.com
